Analysis of Trade Effects of Parallel Exchange Rate in Nigeria

Oluwatosin Juliana Oyetayo *

Department of Banking and Finance, College of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies, Federal University of Agriculture, Abeokuta, Nigeria.

Felix Gbenga Olaifa

Department of Economics, Faculty of Humanities, Management and Social Sciences, Kwara State University, Malete, Ilorin, Nigeria.

Ebenezer Adesoji Olubiyi

Department of Economics, College of Entrepreneurship and Development Studies, Federal University of Agriculture, Abeokuta, Nigeria.

*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.


Abstract

Aims: The study examines the potency of parallel exchange rates in the movement of international trade in Nigeria. The monetary authorities have embarked on various exchange rate regimes basically because the supply of foreign exchange is not enough to meet the demand. Consequently, a parallel market for exchange rates exists and has become a strong and functional market in the country. But the reason for managing foreign exchange and by extension, introducing various exchange rate regimes was to correct the balance of trade disequilibrium. Yet the balance of trade deteriorates, particularly that of non-oil trade balance.  Does the parallel exchange rate contribute to this or does it ameliorate it?  

Study Design: Descriptive, Correlation, and Regression analysis on time series data.

Place and Duration of Study: Sample: Monthly data from January 2007 to December 2022 (2007:1-2022:12) were extracted from the online data repository of the Central Bank of Nigeria.

Methodology: The autoregressive distributed lag technique was employed on monthly data between January 2007 and December 2022 (2007:1-2022:12).

Results: The result indicates that the short-run dynamics of total exports (total imports) are negatively (positively) and significantly affected by parallel exchange rate. Generally, depreciation of the parallel exchange rate is detrimental to export particularly non-oil exports. Further, depreciation of parallel exchange rate encourages imports and highly persistent in influencing non-oil imports.  The J-curve phenomenon breaks down for total balance of trade. However, the J-curve phenomenon cannot be confirmed in the case of oil trade balance because there is no information about the long run effect of parallel exchange rate on oil export due to the non-integration of the model.  In the case of non-oil trade balance, the short-run outcome confirms the existence of the J-curve prediction. 

Conclusion: Following these results, it is recommended among others that government should activate a single market (window) for foreign exchange. Also, the authorities should ensure that importation of non-oil products such as exotic cars by government officials be stemmed.

Keywords: Empirical studies on trade, foreign exchange, monetary policy, trade policy, econometrics


How to Cite

Oyetayo, Oluwatosin Juliana, Felix Gbenga Olaifa, and Ebenezer Adesoji Olubiyi. 2024. “Analysis of Trade Effects of Parallel Exchange Rate in Nigeria”. Asian Journal of Economics, Business and Accounting 24 (6):4-25. https://doi.org/10.9734/ajeba/2024/v24i61339.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Kramer L. How importing and exporting impacts the economy. Investopedia-Economy; 2023. Available:https://text=A%20weaker%20domestic%20currency%20stimulates,such%20as%20materials%20and%20labor

Bergman UM. The portfolio balance model. Lecture note at the University of Copenhagen, Denmark; 2005.

Black SW. The porfolio theory of exchangerates: Then and now. Review of International Economics; 2014. Available:https://doi.10.111/roie.12167

Evans MD, Lyons BK. Portfolio balance, price impact, and secret intervention. SSRN Working Paper; 2022. Available:https://hdl.handle.net/11159/277980

Kallianiotis IN. Exchange rate determination: The portfolio-balance approach. Journal of Applied Finance and Banking. Scienpress ltd. 2021;11(1): 1-20.

Adekoya OB. Portfolio balance approach to asymmetries, structural breaks and financial crisis: Testing a model for Nigeria, portfolio balance theory. CBN Journal of Applied Statistics. 2020;11(1):4. Available:https://dc.cbn.gov.ng/jas/voiii/iss1/4

Tarri R, Gozen MC. Portfolio balance approach to exchange rate determination: Testing a model by applying bilateral data of Turkey and United States. EGE Academic Review. 2018;8(3): 423 -434.

Mogaji PK. Monetary models evaluation of exchange rate determination in the NON-WAEMU Anglophone West Africa and Guinea. MPRA Paper no 99346; 2018. Available:https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/99346/

Kurihara Y, Fukishima A. Monetary approach for determining exchange rates and recent monetary policy of Japan. International Journal of Financial Economics. 2015;4(1):23 -31.

Umoru D. Monetary models and exchange rate determination: The Nigerian evidence. International Journal of Development and Management Review (INJODEMAR). 2013; 8(1):172-197.

Gray ST. Recognizing reality: Official and parallel exchange rates. IMF Working Paper WP/21/25. IMF, Washington D.C, USA; 2021.

Ebaidalla ME. Determinants and macroeconomic impact of parallel exchange rate’s premium in Sudan. African Journal of Economic Review, VII. 2019;(1), Available:https://ajol-file-journals-540_articles_182549_submission_proof_182549-6361-468040-1-10-20190126.pdf

CBN. Foreign exchange rate. Education in Economics Series. Central Bank of Nigeria, Abuja, Nigeria; 2016.

Siddikki J. Black market exchange rate in India: An empirical analysis. Empirical Economics. 2008;25(2):297-333.

Aghenor P. Parallel currency markets in developing countries: Theory evidence, evidence and policy implications. Essays in International Finance No. 188, Princeton University, Princeton, USA; 1992.

Melvin M, Norrbin S. The foreign exchange market. In International Money and Finance (Tenth Edition), Prentice-Hall, New York; 2023.

Onyiriuba L. Foreign exchange markets and triggers for bank risk in developing economies. In Bank Risk Management in Developing Economies. Academic Press, Lagos; 2016.

Moses-Ashike H. Low oil, capital flight shrink external reserves. BusinessDay; 2023. Available:https://businessday.ng/business-economy/article/low-oil-capital-flight-shrink-external-reserves/

Abiola AG, Adedayo FO. Channeling Nigeria’s foreign exchange reserves into alternative investment outlets: A critical analysis. International Journal of Economics and financial Issues. 2013;3(4):813-826.

Nwokories EC, Nwachukwu EO. A model for trading the foreign exchange market. West African Journal of Industrial and Academic Research. 2015;14(1):3-17. Available:https://ajol-file-journals_493_articles_128072_submission_proof_128072-5821-347384-1-10-20160113.pdf

Degefa D. The parallel foregn exchange market and macroeconomic performance in Ethiopia. African Economic Research Consortium (AERC) Research Paper No. 107. Nairobi, Kenya; 2001.

Kaufmann D. The macroeconomics of the unofficial foreign exchange market in Tanzania. In Economic Reform in sub-Saharan Africa, Faculty works, Swathmore College; 1991. Available:https://works.swarthmore.edu/fac-economics/255

UN Globalization and Development. Twenty-ninth session of United Nations-CEPAL, Brazil; 2002. Available:https://repositorio.cepal.org/s200903_en.pdf

Crookes A, Zhang KA, Stodart P. (eds.). Exchnage rates and Trade: Final Report. Economic Insight, London UK; 2022.

Zhang L, Tao K. The benefits and costs of Renminbi internationalization. ADBI Working Paper 481. Asian Development Bank Institute, Tokyo; 2014. Available:http://www.adbi.org/workingpaper/2014/05/19/6266.benefits.costs.renminbi.internationalization/

BIS. Market volatility and foreign exchange intervention in EMEs: What has changed? BIS Papers no. 73; 2013. Available:https://www.bis.org/bispap73/pdf

Kiguel M, O’Connell S. Parallel exchange rate in developing countries: The World Bank Research Observer. 1995;10(1):21-52.

Aron J, Elbadawi I. Parallel markets, the foreign exchange auction, and exchange rate unification in Zambia, World Bank Policy Research Working Papers, WPS No. 909, May; 1992.

Ajinaja O. Impact of exchange rate volatility on export performance in Nigeria’s economy. International Journal of Management and Business Studies. 2017;7(1):40-43.

Musibau H. Exchage rate volatility and non-oil Exporta in Nigeria. Journal of Global Economics. 2017;5(2):1-5.

Oyovwi O. Exchange rate effect on trade variation in Nigeria. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences. 2013;4(6):401-406.

Adaramola A. The effect of real exchange rate on export volume in Nigeria. FUTA Journal of Management and Technology. 2016;1(2):45-61.

Nkurunziza JD. Exchange rate policy and the parallel market for foreign currency in Burundi. AERC Research paper 123, AERC, Nairobi; 2002.

Oworu JE, farayibi AO, Obinwata IB. Exchange rate trends and export performance in Nigeria: A descriptive approach. Munich Personal Repec Archive, Paper 75526; 2016.

Edeme RK, Nkalu NC, Emecheta C, Ugwu S. Trade policies, exchange rate and developing country’s real sector export performance. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues. 2017;7(2):601-607

Ebaidalla W. Determinants and macroeconomic impact of a parallel market for the exchange rate in Sudan. Economic Research Forum Working Paper No. 155, University of Khartoum; 2017.

ITA. Nigeria – Country Commercial Guide. International Trade Adminstration, Washington D.C, USA; 2023.

CBN. Economic Report. CBN, Abuja; 2022.

Ijirshar VU, Okpe IJ, Andohol JT. Impact of exchange rate on trade flow in Nigeria. CBN Journal of Applied Statistics. 2022;185 -222.

Ayomitunde TA, George OA, Pereowei AB, Olatunji OO. Exchange rate volatility and trade balance in Nigeria: An autoregressive distributed lag model approach. EuroEconomica. 2020;39(1). Available:https://dj-univ-danibus.ro/index.php/EE/article/view/242

Dare F, Elijah AO. Exchange rate and balance of payments in Nigeria. EuroEconomica. 2020;39(1):73-83. Available:https://dj.univ.-danibus.ro/index.php/EE/article/view/247/376.

Okonkwo J. Exchange rate variation and Nigeria’s balance of trade. Discovery. 2019;55(283):361-366.

Onakoya AA, Johnson SB. Exchange rate and trade balance: The case for T-curve effect in Nigeria. KIU Journal of Social Sciences. 2018;4(4):47-63.

Ibrahim TR, Akinbobola TO, Ademola IJ. Exchange rate reform policies and trade balances in Nigeria. KJBM. 2017;8(1):14-25.

Igue NN, Ogunleye TS. Impact of real exchange rate trade balance in Nigeria. African Development Review. 2014;26(2):347-358. Available:https://doi.org/10/111/1467-8268.12086

Nwachukwu I. Naira hits new low of N900/1$ After JP Morgan revelations. Businessday; 2023. Available:https://businessday.ng/business-economy/article/naira-hits-new-low-of-900-after-jp-morgan-revelations/

AFREXIM Bank. Export manaufacturing and regional value chains in Africa under a new world order. In Africa Trade Report. AFREXIM Bank, Egypt; 2023.

Thi Thanh Tu Tran T. Impact of bank credit on exports to Association of South East Asian nations countries: Empirical study of Vietnam. Asia and the Pacific Policy Studies. 2019;7(1):27-42. Available:https://doi.org/10.1002/app5.290.

Munoz S. Zimbabwe export performance: The impact of parallel market and governance factors. International Monetary Fund Working Paper No. 84, IMF, Washington, USA; 2006.

Schanz J. Foreign exchange reserves in Africa: Benefits, costs and political economy considerations. Bank for International Settlement (BIS) Papers no 105. BIS, Basel, Netherlands.

Mansaray, B.B. (2018). The impact of trade on the foreign exchange reserves of Sierra-Leone. International Journal of Research Publications. 2019;19(1). Available:https://doi.org/10091122018473

Nteegah A, Okpoi GE. External trade and its implications on foreign exchange reserves in Nigeria. West African Journal of Industrial and Academic Research. 2017;108-119. Available:https://ajol-file-journals_493_articles_156647_submission_proof_156647-5821-408504-1-10-20170526.pdf.

Sahel, West Africa Club. Prospects for trade between Nigeria and its neighbours. OECD Publishing; 2001 Feb 28.